My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria
Your Local Arcadia Pizza Shop
welcome friends
Go Ahead and
Build Your
Own Pizza
We Won’t
Judge!
Pizza Slices
Traditional NY Style Slice
SOUTHWESTERN STYLE SLICE
AL PASTOR SLICE
CARNE ASADA SLICE
Build Your Own Pizza 12″ & 18″
12" Traditional NY Style Slice
New York Thin Crust, House Red Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese and Oregano. A classic.
12" SOUTHWESTERN STYLE SLICE
New York Thin Crust, Southwest Fire Roasted Jalapeno Tomato Cream and Mozzarella Cheese. An Arizona Favorite!
12" Gluten Free Traditional NY Style
New York GLUTEN FREE Thin Crust, House Red Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese and Oregano. A classic.
12" Gluten Free Southwestern Style
New York GLUTEN FREE Thin Crust, Southwest Fire Roasted Jalapeno, Tomato Cream and Mozzarella Cheese. An Arizona Favorite!
18" Traditional NY Style
New York Thin Crust, House Red Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese and Oregano. A classic.
18" Southwestern Style
New York Thin Crust, Southwest Fire Roasted Jalapeno, Tomato Cream and Mozzarella Cheese. An Arizona Favorite!
Pizza Toppings
Standard Toppings Per Slice
Premium Toppings Per Slice
Standard Toppings Per 12"
Premium Toppings Per 12"
Standard Toppings Per 18"
Premium Toppings Per 18"
Standard Veggies
Black Olive, Cherry Pepper, Cilantro, Fire Roasted Diced Green Chili, Fire Roasted Jalapenos Rings. Fresh Basil, Fresh Garlic, Green Bell Pepper, Grilled Pineapple, Jalapeno, Mushroom, Pepperoncini, Red Onion, Roasted Corn, Roma Tomato, Spinach
Standard Meats
Anchovies, Bacon, Diced Grilled Chicken, Canadian Bacon, Pepperoni, Salami, Sausage
Standard Cheeses
Bleu Cheese Crumble, Mozzarella, Provolone
Premium Veggies
Fire Roasted Artichoke, House Roasted Garlic, Sun-Dried Tomato
Premium Meats
Al Pastor, Carne Asada, House-made Meatballs, Schreiner’s Chorizo
Premium Cheeses
Blended Parmesan, Cotija, Fresh Mozzarella, Ricotta
Premium Additional
Avocado Puree, Crema, Fire Roasted Jalapeno Puree, Fire Roasted Habanero Puree, Fire Roasted Tomato Salsa, Spiced Crema
SPECIALTY PIZZAS
Southwest Veggin Out
Southwest Sauce, Mozzarella, Roma Tomato, Diced Green Chili, Roasted Corn, Red Onion, Fresh Garlic, Queso Fresco, Cilantro, Cotija
The VEG
House-made Sauce, Four Cheese Blend, Mushroom, Green Bell Pepper, Roma Tomato ,Red Onion, Fresh Garlic, Fresh Basil, Ricotta, Oregano.
Supremo
Southwest Sauce, Mozzarella, Asadero, Pollo Asado, Schreiner’s Chorizo, Diced Green Chili, Red Onion, Roasted Corn, Fresh Garlic, Cilantro, Cotija
Barb-Ba-Que-Onda
House made BBQ Mole Sauce, Mozzarella, Pollo Asado, Roasted Jalapeno, Red Onion, Spiced Crema, Cilantro, Cotija
The Supreme Being
House-made Sauce, Four Cheese Blend, Mushroom, Pepperoni, Sausage, Green Bell Pepper, Red Onion, Black Olive, Fresh Garlic, Bacon, Oregano
El Blanco
Roasted Jalapeno Garlic Olive Oil, Four Cheese Blend, Asadero, Roma Tomato, Fire Roasted Artichoke, Roasted Red Pepper, Ricotta, Fresh Garlic, Fresh Basil, Cotija
Al Pastor WHAT?
Southwest Sauce, Mozzarella, Asadero, Al Pastor, Red Onion, Grilled Pineapple, Cilantro, Cotija, Fire Roasted Jalapeno Puree
You Gotta Carne Asada
Southwest Sauce, Fresh Garlic, Roma Tomato, Chargrilled Carne Asada, Red Onion, Mozzarella, Fire Roasted Tomato Salsa, Avocado Puree, Crema, Cilantro, Cotija
GF The Marge
Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil. Roma Tomato, Presto! GLUTEN FREE
The Marge
Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil. Roma Tomato, Presto!
Salads
The Casa
Lettuce Blend, Roma Tomato, Cucumber, Radish, Red Onion. Choice of Dressing (House Ranch, Green Chili Cucumber Ranch, House Caesar, Bleu Cheese, Italian, Balsamic Vin, Olive Oil and Vinegar)
Against-Pasta
Lettuce Blend, Sliced Red Onion, Cucumber Black Olive, Green Bell Pepper, Roasted Artichoke Provolone, Salami, Italian Dressing
Lil Caesar
Romaine, Croutons, Caesar Dressing, Shaved Parmesan Blend, Grated Parmesan
Rise Like A Phoenix
Lettuce Blend, Spinach, Roasted Corn, Red Onion, Roma Tomato, Diced Green Chili, Cherry Pepper, Asadero, Green Chili Cucumber Ranch, Cotija
The Pop-Eye
Spinach, Roma Tomato, Red Onion, Mushroom, Bleu Cheese Dressing, Bleu Cheese Crumble
Salad Dressings
Ranch, Green Chili, Cucumber Ranch, Italian Cesar, Balsamic Vinaigrette
Additional Dressings
Add Grilled Chicken
Add Mozzarella Cheese
SANDWICHES
Veg Sand
Roma Tomato, Spinach, Fire Roasted Artichoke, Roasted Red Pepper, Red Onion, Italian Dressing
Italian Deli
Salami, Pepperoni, Ham, Provolone, Roasted Red Pepper, Peppercini, Red Onion, Italian Dressing
The Meatball
Home-made Meatballs, Marinara, Provolone
Desert Chicken
Grilled Chicken Breast, Southwest Sauce, Diced Green Chili.
The Chorizo-Wich
Schreiners Chorizo, Chicken, Southwest Sauce, Diced Green Chili, Corn.
Add Fresh Mozzarella
SIDES AND EXTRAS
House Made Meatballs
14 ingredient House made meatballs baked to perfection. Served in a spiced marinara. Topped with parmesan. (Melted mozzarella optional.)
Spaghetti
Elote Flatbread
Roasted Jalapeno Garlic Olive Oil, Minced Garlic, Mayonnaise, White Sweet Corn, Cotija Cheese, Spiced Crema w/ Tajin (citrus seasoning)
Garlic Bread Sticks
w/ 1 Sauce
w/ 2 Sauces
House Roasted Garlic oven baked on top our homemade pizza dough. Finished with House Roasted Jalapeno Garlic Oil and Oregano. Perfect size for dipping and sharing!
Garlic Cheese Bread
w/ 1 Sauce
w/ 2 Sauces
Melted Mozzarella, House Roasted Garlic oven baked on top our homemade pizza dough. Finished with House Roasted Jalapeno Garlic Oil and Oregano.
Garlic Toast
Extra Meatball
Extra Mozzarella
WINGS
Sweet And Sassy
Carolina Gold Base (Mild Heat)
Chorizo Prickly Pear Glaze
Sweet front with unique seasoned back end (Mild Heat)
BBQ Mole
BBQ forward with Mole influences (Mild Heat)
Old School Frankie
Franks Buffalo Medium Sauce (Medium Heat)
Pina Y Habanero
Sweet and flavorful front with back end spiced kick (Hot!)
WING SAUCE
2 Ounce Dressing with 1/2 Dozen Order
3 Ounce Dressing with 1/2 Dozen Order
Additional 2 Ounce Dressing
Additional 3 Ounce Dressing
Drinks & Desserts
SOFT DRINKS
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper
Mexican Coke (Grande)
San Pellegrino Sparking Flavored Water
DESERTS
New York Style Cheesecake
Seasonal Cheesecake
About Us
Welcome to My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria – Arcadia. We are a family-owned and -operated business that offers New York traditions fused with Mexican and Southwestern flavor. We have established a reputation for providing high-quality food, excellent customer service, and speedy delivery to customers in the Arcadia area. We can promise satisfaction because all of our dishes are freshly prepared every day with premium ingredients. At My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria, we are where New York meets the Southwest.
