Your Local Phoenix Pizza Shop

NY Style Thin Crust Pizza for Delivery, Takeout & Dine In

Where NY Meets The Southwest

Welcome to My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria – Arcadia. We are a family-owned and operated business that offers New York traditions fused with Mexican and Southwestern flavor. We have established a reputation for providing high quality food, excellent customer service, and speedy pizza delivery to customers in the Arcadia area. We can promise satisfaction because all of our dishes are freshly prepared every day with premium ingredients for our thin crust pizzas. That's why we have some of the Best Pizza in Phoenix. At My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria, we are where New York meets the Southwest.

Order Online

Specialty Brick Oven Pizzas

BYO Pizza

Salads

Pastas

Sandwiches

Appetizers

Desserts

Specialty Brick Oven Pizzas

*Menu Changes regularly*

AL PASTOR WHAT?

Southwest Sauce, Mozzarella, Asadero, Al Pastor, Red Onion, Grilled Pineapple, Cilantro, Cotija, Fire Roasted Jalapeno Puree

THE SUPREME BEING

House-made Sauce, Four Cheese Blend, Mushroom, Pepperoni, Sausage, Green Bell Pepper, Red Onion, Black Olive, Fresh Garlic, Bacon, Oregano

THE MARG

Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil. Roma Tomato, Presto!

You Gotta Carne Asada

Southwest Sauce, Fresh Garlic, Roma Tomato, Chargrilled Carne Asada, Red Onion, Mozzarella, Fire Roasted Tomato Salsa, Avocado Puree, Crema, Cilantro, Cotija

Sonoran Pizza

Southwest Sauce, Mozzarella, Roma Tomato, Diced Green Chili, Roasted Corn, Red Onion, Fresh Garlic, Cilantro, Cotija.

THE VEG

House-made Sauce, Four Cheese Blend, Mushroom, Green Bell Pepper, Roma Tomato ,Red Onion, Fresh Garlic, Fresh Basil, Ricotta, Oregano.

EL Rey

Southwest Sauce, Mozzarella, Asadero, Pollo Asado, Schreiner’s Chorizo, Diced Green Chili, Red Onion, Roasted Corn, Fresh Garlic, Cilantro, Cotija

BARB-BA-QUE-ONDA

House made BBQ Mole Sauce, Mozzarella, Pollo Asado, Roasted Jalapeno, Red Onion, Spiced Crema, Cilantro, Cotija

El Blanco

Roasted Jalapeno Garlic Olive Oil, Four Cheese Blend, Asadero, Roma Tomato, Fire Roasted Artichoke, Roasted Red Pepper, Ricotta, Fresh Garlic, Fresh Basil, Cotija

Meatlovers

Red Sauce, Pepperoni, Bacon, Sausage & Meatballs

Build Your Own

Home Made Pies, Made Fresh

Standard Toppings

Veggies

Red Onion, Roma Tomato, Black Olive, Fresh Garlic, Mushroom, Grilled Pineapple, Green Bell Pepper, Peppercini, Cherry Pepper, Fresh Basil, Fire Roasted Diced Green Chili, Roasted Corn, Cilantro, Fire Roasted Jalapeño Rings

Meats

Anchovies, Bacon, Pepperoni, Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Salami, Diced Grilled Chicken

Add'l

Crema • Spiced Crema • Fire Roasted Jalapeño Purée • Fire Roasted Habanero Purée • Avocado Purée • Fire Roasted Tomato Salsa

Premium Toppings

Veggies

Fire Roasted Artichoke, Sun Dried Tomato, House Roasted Garlic

Meats

Prosciutto, Al Pastor, Schreiner’s Chorizo, House-made Meatballs, Carne Asada.

Cheese

Blended Parmesan, Ricotta, Cotija, Fresh Mozzarella or switch to Vegan Cheese.

Salads

Fresh Salads

THE CASA

Lettuce Blend, Roma Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion. Choice of Dressing

ANTIPASTO

Lettuce Blend, Sliced Red Onion, Cucumber Black Olive, Green Bell Pepper, Roasted Artichoke Provolone, Salami, Italian Dressing

LIL CAESAR

Romaine, Croutons, Caesar Dressing, Shaved Parmesan Blend, Grated Parmesan

Pastas

Get Your Pastas

Spaghetti

Made with Our Spicy Marinara. Optional Meatballs can be added for an extra charge.

Kids Spaghetti

Made with our NY Pizza Sauce

Lasagna

Made with our Spicy Marinara, Schreiner’s Sausage, Meatballs, mozzarella, and ricotta cheese

Sandwiches

*Menu Changes regularly*

THE MEATBALL

Home-made Meatballs, Marinara, Provolone

ITALIAN DELI

Salami, Pepperoni, Ham, Provolone, Roasted Red Pepper, Peppercini, Red Onion, Italian Dressing

Appetizers

*Menu Changes regularly*

Wings

Flavors: Sweet & Sassy, Frankies Buffalo, Habanero Pina, Lemon Pepper, Garlic Parmesan

Housemade Meatballs

14 ingredient House made meatballs baked to perfection. Served in a spiced marinara. Topped with parmesan. (Melted mozzarella optional.)

Elote Flatbread

Roasted Jalapeno Garlic Olive Oil, Minced Garlic, Mayonnaise, White Sweet Corn, Cotija Cheese, Spiced Crema w/ Tajin (citrus seasoning)

Garlic Breadsticks

Garlic Cheesebread

Fries

Garlic Knots

Irresistible garlic knots: golden, buttery, and packed with savory garlic flavor. The perfect pizza companion.

Desserts

*Menu Changes regularly*

Your Local Phoenix Pizza Shop

NY Style Thin Crust Pizza for Delivery, Takeout & Dine In

Where NY Meets The Southwest

Featured In

Menu

Specialty Brick Oven Pizzas

AL PASTOR WHAT?

THE SUPREME BEING

THE MARG

You Gotta Carne Asada

Sonoran Pizza

THE VEG

EL Rey

BARB-BA-QUE-ONDA

El Blanco

Meatlovers

Build Your Own

Standard Toppings

Premium Toppings

Salads

THE CASA

ANTIPASTO

LIL CAESAR

Pastas

Spaghetti

Kids Spaghetti

Lasagna

Sandwiches

THE MEATBALL

ITALIAN DELI

Appetizers

Wings

Housemade Meatballs

Elote Flatbread

Garlic Breadsticks

Garlic Cheesebread

Fries

Garlic Knots

Desserts

New York Style Cheesecake

Specialty / Seasonal Cheesecake