About us

My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria – Where New York Meets the Southwest

At My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria, we’re passionate about pizza and trying new flavors. In fact, our owner, Phoenix native and Camelback High School graduate, Randy Bortin, put everything on the line, including selling his house to deliver you his unique vision of Southwestern style pizza and authentic New York style pizza at family friendly prices here in Phoenix, AZ.

New York Pizza With A Twist in Phoenix, AZ

When you come into My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria in the heart of Phoenix’s Arcadia area, you’ll be able to choose between the more familiar and traditional fare like New York Style thin crust pizza, homemade meatball and other Italian style sandwiches, delicious salads, and wings.

But if you’re feeling adventurous and want to try something different, then take your inspiration from Randy and go all in on one of our signature Southwestern style pizzas. Influenced by the flavors of Mexico, you’ll love trying our specialty pizzas such as the Al Pastor or the Supremo.

Or if you’re unsure, try the Southwestern sauce of fire-roasted habanero and jalapeno tomato cream on your favorite traditional pizza instead of our housemade traditional tomato sauce.

Dine In, Carry Out, & Limited Area Delivery

We want to you to feel at home and welcome here at My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria. Randy is here almost every day and he might even be the one who delivers your pizza to you. And speaking of delivery, if you’re in the Arcadia and immediately surrounding areas of Phoenix, we deliver within a 3-mile radius of the restaurant. Or come visit us and get your pie to go instead. If you have more time, bring your family to eat with us in our relaxing dining room where you sit back and enjoy each others company. We are excited to announce that in the near future we will be serving beer and wine at our location in Arcadia! We will have a rotating list of domestic, imported, and local craft beers as well as a changing selection of wine. Check back for more details.

Come taste our Southwestern Pizza & see why dough-heads in Phoenix love us!

If you’re looking for authentic New York Style pizza with a taste of the Southwest, look no further than My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria in Phoenix, AZ. Come get a pizza this today!